ARTICLES AND PRESENTATIONS

Jason and Kadey
Search For a Topic
Search
The Duty of Utmost Good Faith
by Kadey B.J. Schultz 2022-04-12
READ NOW
READ SUMMARY

This paper on the duty of utmost good faith in the context of auto insurance and accident benefits is to be published in the Oatley McLeish Guide for Motor Vehicle Accidents. The paper outlines the legal history of this duty, beginning with Smith v. Cooperators and proceeding to more recent cases such as Tomec v. Economical. 


It also addresses the manner in which the duty cuts both ways, with the establishment of the independent actionable wrong principle from Whiten v. Pilot, and the possibility for insureds to pay punitive damages to insurers when they breach this duty, such as in RBC General Insurance v. Field. 


The paper discusses the consumer protection purpose of accident benefits legislation in Ontario, and provides a primer on the impact of self-representation by insured persons. 


It was authored by Kadey B.J. Schultz, and Colin MacDonald, and presented at the Osgoode Certificate in Motor Vehicle Accident Law and Practice: Tort and Accident Benefits Conference on April 12, 2022.


 

The Duty of Utmost Good Faith
by Colin MacDonald 2022-04-12
READ NOW
READ SUMMARY

This paper on the duty of utmost good faith in the context of auto insurance and accident benefits is to be published in the Oatley McLeish Guide for Motor Vehicle Accidents. The paper outlines the legal history of this duty, beginning with Smith v. Cooperators and proceeding to more recent cases such as Tomec v. Economical. 


It also addresses the manner in which the duty cuts both ways, with the establishment of the independent actionable wrong principle from Whiten v. Pilot, and the possibility for insureds to pay punitive damages to insurers when they breach this duty, such as in RBC General Insurance v. Field. 


The paper discusses the consumer protection purpose of accident benefits legislation in Ontario, and provides a primer on the impact of self-representation by insured persons. 


It was authored by Kadey B.J. Schultz, and Colin MacDonald, and presented at the Osgoode Certificate in Motor Vehicle Accident Law and Practice: Tort and Accident Benefits Conference on April 12, 2022


 

With police operations underway, uncertainty around Emergencies Act continues
by Kadey B.J. Schultz 2022-02-18
READ NOW
READ SUMMARY

The federal government’s Emergencies Act requires insurance companies to “immediately cease” auto insurance coverage to Freedom Convoy protestors. But the act is noticeably silent on whose insurance should be suspended or how it should be done. All that is known at the moment is that the Emergencies Act trumps notice of cancellation requirements established in provincial law.


How the Emergencies Act is to be enacted is a hot topic in the Canadian P&C industry. 


Kadey Schultz of Schultz Frost LLP says the act could cause “long-tail financial” effects for both insurers and insureds.  


Read the full article in Canadian Undewriter by clicking on "Read Now", above. 

Kadey Schultz, Lexpert Zenith Mid-Career Excellence Award Winner!
by the firm 2018-06-19
READ NOW
READ SUMMARY

Kadey was recognized once again by Lexpert with the Zenith Mid-Career Excellence Award.

Law Times Article: Insurance Defence Boutiques Have Flexibility in Approach
by Michael McKiernan 2016-03-28
READ NOW
READ SUMMARY


Kadey B.J. Schultz and Jason Frost present their views on the evolving role of insurance defence litigation firms and how Schultz Frost LLP plays a unique, consultative role, partnering with clients to manage risk and reduce reliance on outside counsel. 

Presentation: Before the Changes Come - The Top Ten AB Cases of 2015
by Kadey B.J. Schultz 2016-02-03
READ NOW
READ SUMMARY
What you need to know about the latest developments in Accident Benefits!

Get up to speed on changes regarding:


- The ability of insurers to conduct EUOs

- Why catastrophic impairment is NOT a benefit (and the implications)

- Limitation periods

- Interest on retroactive attendant care benefits

- Loss transfer in chain reaction collisions
Presentation: Cyber Risk in Canada -- What to Watch Out for and How to Be Prepared
by Kadey B.J. Schultz 2016-02-02
READ NOW
READ SUMMARY
This dynamic OBA Institute presentation focuses on Cyber Risk, Privacy Laws, New IIROC Best Practices and Must-Do's for law firm security in 2016.
ONCA Confirms Absurdity of Superior Court's Rule 9 Interpretation
by Kadey B.J. Schultz 2015-10-20
READ NOW
READ SUMMARY
With a unanimous 3-0 decision, the Court of Appeal confirms that heavy commercial vehicle insurers only pay loss transfer to insurers of vehicles with which they actually collide under Rules 9 and 11 of the Fault Determination Rules.

Investigators Trawl Social Media to Catch Fraud
by Sara Tatelman 2015-05-01
READ NOW
READ SUMMARY
It starts like any love story: twenty-something girl meets car. Girl and car get into a crash. Girl files a catastrophic injury claim with her insurance company. Then girl goes off the grid.
Phish Tales
by Kadey B.J. Schultz and Aleksandra Zivanovic 2015-04-16
READ NOW
READ SUMMARY

Cyber criminals have perpetrated - and continue to perpetrate - on banks around the world a spin on the classic bait-and-switch manoeuvre. The new form of phishing has already proved very costly and should serve as a caution that all industries, not just financial institutions, need to develop cyber resilience to avoid getting hooked in.

Moving Target
by Angela Stelmakowich 2015-03-01
READ NOW
READ SUMMARY
Cyber risk is evolving. Despite recent high-profile attacks meant to disparage, disrupt and produce fear, though, a true picture of cyber risk involves far more than intended events. Risk managers must, first, accept the breathtaking breadth of the risk and, second, be ready to absorb information that will help them to set an accurate sight on what is (and will continue to be) a moving target.
10 Decisions that will Impact your Motor Vehicle Litigation Practice
by Kadey B.J. Schultz and Anne Fyfe 2015-02-04
READ NOW
READ SUMMARY

The essential insurance law update from the OBA Institute's 2015 CPD Seminar on February 4, 2015, featuring important cases dealing with priority, deflection, loss transfer, attendant care benefits, interest, threshold, and more.

Game Changer
by Angela Stelmakowich 2013-01-13
READ NOW
READ SUMMARY
Will recommendations contained in the Ontario Automobile Insurance Anti-Fraud Task Force report be a game changer, addressing what has become an increasingly organized and expensive problem? Or could implementation and timing issues threaten to alter the carefully plotted road map for improving the system?
Managing Auto Fraud
by Kadey B.J. Schultz and Chris Rain, VP Claims, Arch Insurance for Canadian Underwriter 2012-05-01
READ NOW
READ SUMMARY
Kadey B.J. Schultz and Chris Rain, Arch Insurance Vice President of Claims, consider how to apply risk management principles to prevent auto insurance fraud.
Access to Private Facebook Pages a Question of Logistics, Not Privacy
by Canadian Underwriter 2011-12-01
READ NOW
READ SUMMARY
Defence counsel's use of private Facebook pages in litigation is not an issue of breaching the plaintiff's privacy so much as it's an issue of logistics and the timing associated with accessing information on private pages.
Litigation Looms Over Minor Injury Cases
by Judy Van Rhijn 2011-10-17
READ NOW
READ SUMMARY
Many insurance industry professionals are predicting a deluge of litigation over the many uncertainties associated with the application of the minor injury guidelines.
The Era of Active Communication
by Kadey B.J. Schultz 2011-09-01
READ NOW
READ SUMMARY
Ontario's auto reforms highlight the importance of documenting all communications with consumers - even if those communications prove to be entirely one-sided.
Falling Under
by Laura Kupcis 2011-08-05
READ NOW
READ SUMMARY
While more than 50 per cent of all claims in Ontario are currently falling under the MIG, this could have serious cost ramifications in future if case law does not favour insurers who are applying the MIG prior to the renewal date.
More than 50% of all AB Claims Falling Under the MIG
by Canadian Underwriter 2011-05-16
READ NOW
READ SUMMARY
The issue is not how many claims fall into the MIG at the outset, but how many stay in the MIG, which will only be borne out by time and the development of case law.
Language Divide
by Vanessa Mariga 2011-05-01
READ NOW
READ SUMMARY
A government blue-ribbon panel of medical experts has produced a proposed new draft of Ontario's catastrophic impairment definition, including a welcomed "line in the sand" against combining physical and psychological impairments to determine whole person impairment. But how will the medical terminology in the new definition be translated into the language of case law?
Hitting the Mark Aiming for Successful SABS & MIG Outcomes
by Laura Kupcis 2011-04-01
READ NOW
READ SUMMARY
The more things change, the more they stay the same. Slightly more than six months after the rollout of the revamped Statutory Accident Benefits Schedule (SABS), including the implementation of the Minor Injury Guideline (MIG), health care providers have raised concerns about decisions adjusters are making with respect to a claimant's health. Conversely, adjusters are raising concerns about health care providers' treatment requests made on behalf of claimants.
Best Practices Help to Avoid Special Arbitration Awards When No Benefits are in Dispute
by Canadian Underwriter 2011-02-09
READ NOW
READ SUMMARY
A recent Financial Services Commission of Ontario (FSCO) decision - which granted a special award when there were no benefits in dispute - should prompt adjusters to follow a set of best practices to avoid a similar decision in the future.
Loosening the Cap
by Vanessa Mariga 2011-01-01
READ NOW
READ SUMMARY
When the Financial Services Commission of Ontario (FSCO) placed a $2,000 limit on AB assessments under its Minor Injury Guideline (MIG) in September 2010, it intended to restrict a ballooning area of expense for insurers. But now, four months into the reforms, a debate has opened about whether the restriction is in fact too tight.
Ontario's $2,000 Cap on AB Assessments Could be Vulnerable to Charter Challenge: AB seminar panelist
by Canadian Underwriter 2010-11-01
READ NOW
READ SUMMARY
By including a health practitioner's travel and translation costs within a $2,000 limit on auto insurance accident benefits assessments, the new Ontario auto insurance reforms may be heading down the highway towards a Charter challenge.
Defining Minor Injury
by Laura Kupcis 2010-10-01
READ NOW
READ SUMMARY
While the insurance industry is hopeful the new Minor Injury Guideline (MIG) will successfully curb claims costs, there is an underlying current of fear that perceived loopholes in the MIG might thwart its effectiveness.
A $25,000 Question?
by Kadey B.J. Schultz 2009-12-01
READ NOW
READ SUMMARY
An award of aggravated damages for mental distress exceeding the value of the benefits in dispute.
Group or Category
Search by Lawyer